Friday, November 13, 2026

Coaches, Reserve Judgment (especially negative judgment)

*******************************************************************************************************************
You can find My Coaches Couch, the podcast (with different content) in your favorite podcast app or at MyCoachesCouch.podbean.com.
*******************************************************************************************************************

Author F. Scott Fitzgerald shared wisdom that applies to asking questions when coaching: “Reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope.” When coaches are open to the unique answers teachers might provide, they are showing confidence and hope in the teachers they work with. These positive assumptions about teachers’ abilities restrain judgment – especially negative judgment. When we ask authentic, curious questions before jumping to judgment, the answers teachers offer move coaching conversations in a positive direction.
 
During classroom observations, it’s easy to judge. But feeling judged siphons a teachers’ energy into defensiveness and self-protection. So, as we plan for debrief conversations, it helps to step away from judgments we may have made and instead ask questions that help us to understand the teacher’s thinking.
 
When I observed Bailey’s kindergarten class during math, students were compliant and busy. They were following familiar routines as they counted and recorded their thinking. The lesson seemed predictable, and concerns popped into my head. Students didn’t appear particularly challenged, the activity wasn’t differentiated, and the closing discussion didn’t seem purposeful.
 
But when we got together to talk about the lesson, I held back. Rather than jumping in with concerns, I asked questions. As Bailey reflected on her planning and teaching decisions, some of her responses surprised me, revealing thoughtful intentions I hadn't recognized during the observation. In addition to clarifying my understanding of the lesson, our conversation prompted "aha" moments for Bailey that guided her planning. She also recognized the need to stay connected to her lesson plans and to be clearer about learning outcomes. Questions and conversation brought her further than judgments would have.
 
The conversation reminded me that what we see in a classroom doesn't tell us the whole story. Before making judgments about what's missing, it helps to ask questions that help us understand the teacher's thinking.
 
Going into our debrief conversation, I hadn’t been sure what the outcomes would be, but Bailey’s responses to my questions illuminated for her where she wanted to turn her attention. Restraining judgment and, instead, asking questions encouraged Bailey to take a more active role during our debrief conversation.
 
Reserving judgment doesn't mean ignoring concerns and pretending everything is working well. It means remaining open to what we don't yet know. When coaches approach conversations with curiosity rather than conclusions, they show confidence in teachers' capacity to reflect, learn, and make thoughtful decisions. Because coaches have expertise and experience, it can be easy to jump to judgment and recommend. But asking questions encourages teachers to draw from their own wells of experience. Reserving judgement in coaching shows we believe there's more to discover and more potential to uncover when we take time to ask.
 
This week, you might want to take a look at:

Managing your capacity:
 
https://www.learningforwardtexas.org/post/what-does-this-require-of-your-capacity
 
 
Project-Based Learning & Global Citizenship:
 
https://www.edutopia.org/article/pbl-global-classroom-partnerships
 
 
Verbal rehearsal supports students’ writing:
 
https://www.k12dive.com/news/verbal-rehearsal-may-help-students-overcome-writing-challenges/873723/ 
 
 
Teaching students to self-monitor their behavior:
 
http://www.responsiveclassroom.org/teaching-children-to-check-their-own-behavior/
 
 
Sometimes doing better means doing less:
 
https://hiddenbrain.org/podcast/do-less/
 
That’s it for this week. Happy Coaching!

Want more coaching tips? Check out my book, Differentiated Mentoring & Coaching in Education: From Preservice Teacher to Expert Practitioner, available from Teachers College Press!  I’m so excited to share it with you! TODAY you can use the code: NOV2026 for 15% off. Click  here  and I’ll email you the free Book Group Study Guide that includes questions, prompts, and activities you can use as you share the book with colleagues.  I hope you’ll love this book as much as I loved making it for you!

No comments:

Post a Comment