*******************************************************************************************************************
You
can find My Coaches Couch, the podcast (with
different content) in your favorite podcast app or at MyCoachesCouch.podbean.com.
*******************************************************************************************************************
“Humility is not thinking less of
yourself, it is thinking of yourself less.” ~C.S.
Lewis
Coaches are usually hired because they
have extensive knowledge and experience. The trust that is necessary for
coaching includes both relational trust and experiential trust. The teachers
you are working with need to feel seen and safe in your presence, and they also
need to feel that you are credible and that you believe they are, too.
Credibility comes from knowing that you are drawing from your own experience
and from your knowledge in the field. Teachers need to know they can trust any guidance
you might provide. So they have to know you know some things! However, your
confidence will be best received if it is quiet confidence paired with
curiosity and humility.
“Wait,” you might be wondering, “Can confidence
and humility co-exist?” The answer is, “Yes!” and they
should. The trick here is recognizing that confidence and humility are not two
ends of the same continuum, but rather the hoped-for ends of different continuums.*
Confidence and Humility
Yes, we can aim for confidence
and humility at the same time. What we are avoiding is shame and pride.
Confidence is the opposite of shame.
Shame is negative self-judgment. It is embarrassment, guilt, and humiliation. Don’t
go there! Confidence, on the other hand, is a recognition of one’s own
capability. It is self-efficacy, knowing that we can make a difference. Let’s
lean away from shame and toward confidence!
Confidence, however, does not equal
pride. They are not even on the same spectrum! Pride is ego and conceit. It is an
ostentatious display and puffed-up-edness. It will not serve us well as
coaches. The truly wise coach will recognize that keeping her ego in check is
necessary for developing and sustaining coaching relationships. Be a humble servant-leader.
Side-by-Side
Coaches are sometimes cautioned against
spending time as the “helper” – the runner of copies, the orderer of supplies.
While it’s true that coaches must guard their time and that direct work with
teachers is most impactful, the quickest way I ever earned trust was stapling a
border on a bulletin board.
When I was working as a district
literacy coordinator, I was assigned to support teachers at a school that had
just been labeled, “Turnaround,” meaning that if they didn’t turn things
around, they’d be taken over. Needless to say, it was a tense environment! When I showed up for the first meeting, Elana,
the instructional coach, welcomed me from atop a folding chair, where she was
putting up a bulletin board. “What can I do to help?” I asked, knowing, like
she did, that the superintendent would be making a “surprise” visit in about an
hour. Between the two of us, we quickly
finished the bulletin board, stapling up statements of district and school
goals to greet school visitors. I
noticed several teachers pause in their treks down the hall and look up at me,
questioning. Later, Elana told me, “You
won a lot of trust that way.” Rolling up
my sleeves and stapling a few papers before the superintendent’s visit helped
teachers feel that I was on their side,
working with them, not on them.
Like my stance on the chair in the
hall, coaching with confidence is a tenuous position: from confidence, we can
too easily teeter to pride. If we go into conversations with our minds made up
or with the idea that we need to impart wisdom, the door for dialogue and trust
is shut. Instead, we can cultivate humility.
Sustaining Humility
Humility is a mindset about how we
approach those we are working with. Are we stand-and-deliver directors or side-by-side
partners? Humility establishes a productive horizontal stance with teachers,
rather than a vertical, authoritative stance over them. We can acknowledge and
draw on teachers’ expertise and experience while sharing our own.
In effective teacher-coach
relationships, ideas flow easily both ways. Rather than jumping in to share our
ideas first, though, in order to overcome biases about vertical leadership, as
coaches, we may need to hold our ideas and talk later, so that teachers are
encouraged to lead out with their own thoughts.
To move forward in a coaching cycle, I
have to shift the focus from me and what I know to the teacher and what she
knows. It’s not hard to make a recommendation when a teacher asks for support.
It’s much harder to hold my tongue and instead of sharing my ideas, ask a
question that allows a teacher to share hers. She doesn’t need to know how
smart I am; she needs to know how smart she is. My questions can help her
realize that she really does have answers.
If I ask, “What else have you been
considering?” my question affirms the teacher as one who thoughtfully
deliberates her decisions.
If I ask, “What did you notice about
students’ thinking?” my question recognizes her thoughtful observations.
Questions like these that hold positive
assumptions about teachers’ actions and abilities build teachers’ confidence
and encourage ongoing use of the attributes that have been noted. This coaching
move also sustains my humility as I see and acknowledge the wisdom of others.
Nurturing humility requires profound
self-reflection, recognizing what we do not know and do not understand. We need
the teacher to educate us about their own experience and the experiences of
their students. As we listen deeply and interact empathically, we gain a better
understanding of the teacher’s wisdom.
Sustaining Confidence
Beginning coaches, especially, might
experience Imposter syndrome. We feel elevated responsibility because of our
new role. Sometimes we want to demonstrate our authority or ability. But confidence
in the coaching role doesn’t mean knowing everything; it means offering your knowledge
with humility and genuine curiosity. When teachers feel both seen and
respected, coaching partnerships flourish.
It can sometimes be hard to pull away
from our own knowledge and experience. We have to mentally set aside the answer
we would give so that we can care more about the teacher’s response.
A friend recently told me about her own
child’s elementary school art teacher.
Let’s call the child Emily and the art teacher Mrs. Bard. Emily was working on a drawing during art
class, sketching it out with a pencil before applying paint. Mrs. Bart, wanting to teach about
perspective, erased a line and redrew it at a different angle. The drawing was certainly improved in the
process. When Emily brought the finished
painting home, her mother praised the outcome.
Emily responded, “It’s not my drawing, it Mrs. Bard’s.” Emily lost ownership of her own work through
that erased and redrawn line.
I’ve cautioned against a similar
practice during writing workshop. “Make
sure the pen stays in the child’s hand,” I’ve said, wanting writing conferences
to be meaningful for students. But I
have sometimes been guilty of “stealing the pen” during a coaching
conversation. Sometimes my comment
erases a teacher’s valuable perspective, replacing it with my own view. Instead,
we can grow confident in our role as coaches by seeing the fruits of our
labors: improvement in practice growing from teachers’ own insights.
As coaches, it’s important to be
confident about what we bring to the table, We can be confident that we are
fulfilling our coaching role when we also acknowledge that others bring valid
and valuable knowledge and experience. Coaching is a learning journey we
undertake together.
Be a Co-Learner
You were hired as a coach because you
have knowledge of content and pedagogy.
You know how to teach effectively.
Your job is to help others in their pursuits of improvement, and you
have a lot to give. You know a lot, but
you don’t know everything. Look to the
teachers you are working with to find out what they know. They know about their students. They know about their class’s history. They know about themselves as teachers. That is a lot of knowing!
Coaching trust is built through a
steady presence grounded in both experience and inquiry. When teachers sense
that you truly see them, that you honor their work, and also that you bring
hard-earned knowledge to your conversations, trust grows. It’s not about
showcasing expertise; it’s about offering it with curiosity. Quiet confidence,
paired with genuine curiosity, invites collaboration and deepens the coaching
partnership.
How can you acknowledge that you are a
learner, too? Your stance as co-learner
is evident in your language: in how you make recommendations, in the types of
questions you ask, and in the authenticity of your praise. We can say, “I wonder what would happen
if…..” and truly wonder. We can ask,
“Have you tried…..” because we want to know how past practice is informing
present decisions. We can say, “That’s
such a smart idea!” when it is!
Attributes like humility and confidence
can make or break a coach’s work, even if she has all the right procedures in
place. I’m working to grow these
attributes myself, and I hope sharing these ideas will support you on your own
personal journey. Humility and confidence are important attributes as we forge
relationships and continue to develop our coaching identity.
This
week, you might want to take a look at: